Mistakes Made During PERM Application

lawyers

For employers looking to bring in a permanent foreign worker, the Department of Labor regulates a program called PERM labor certification. This program is handled by an employer, who is required to conduct recruitment and place advertisements for the prospective job to ensure that no qualified U.S. workers are available for the position.

As experienced citizenship and immigration attorneys, we at the offices of Buhler Thomas Law, P.C., see a few common mistakes made during PERM applications. Here are a few of the most frequent, and how you can avoid them

Dates

The PERM process contains strict rules and time frames, including a requirement to place two Sunday advertisements in the newspaper of general circulation in the area where the job opportunity is available. Employers often make the simple mistake of placing one ad on Sunday, and another on a different day – this will lead to denial. The process specifically requires two Sundays, and as we noted, these requirements are strict and unwavering. Make sure all such date-related requirements are followed perfectly.

Past and Present Supervisors

The alien’s past and present work supervisors must be included on forms, but for some reason, employers commonly forget this step. They’ll forget to include names and phone numbers for former employers – once again, this is a detail that will lead directly to denial. This must be done for all past work experience.

DOL Questionnaire

After the employer submits ETA Form 9089 to the DOL, the employer will receive an email with a questionnaire. This questionnaire is to confirm that the employer knowingly filed the form, and that the submission wasn’t the result of spam or a hacker. If an employer doesn’t submit this form within seven days of receiving it, the case will be denied.

Retaining PERM Documentation

Employers must retain all PERM documents at their office for a period of five years – at minimum, this includes prevailing wage determinations, originals of all ads placed for the position, and all resumes the employer received for the job opportunity. Non-compliance here can lead to serious fines or other penalties.

Want to learn more about PERM applications, or interested in any of our other immigration services? Speak to our immigration lawyers at Buhler Thomas Law, P.C. today.

Buhler Thomas Law, P.C.
Excellent
Anna H.
I can't find enough words to thank Kim! She is so amazingly knowledgeable and helped me so much that I can't thank her enough. She answered all questions, gave invaluable advice, and I am so lucky that I had chosen her as a lawyer! Thank you again, Kim!
Response from the owner:It was truly a pleasure meeting with you! The U.S. benefits from individuals like you.
Garrett S.
We cannot thank Kim and her team enough for everything she has done for us. From the very beginning, she went above and beyond with her time, guidance, and support. Her professionalism, knowledge, and compassion made all the difference in our journey, and we truly believe that without her help, the whole process would have been a lot harder.

What sets her apart is not only her expertise, but also dedication she shows to her clients. She always took the time to explain each step clearly, answer our questions thoroughly, and ensure we felt confident and supported throughout the process.

We are deeply grateful for her hard work and commitment, and we look forward to working with her again in the future if needed. We would gladly recommend her to anyone seeking legal help - Kim is, without question, the lawyer you want by your side.
Response from the owner:Thank you! Every attorney is thrilled to have clients like you who were on top of responding to emails.
Autumn B.
Buhler Thomas Law assisted our agency with the H1-B visa process. They were knowledgeable, helpful, and easy to work with throughout the process. We appreciated their guidance and support they provided us.
Response from the owner:Autumn, thank you for being fantastic to work with especially when we would reach out on Fridays.
David G.
Kim helped me get the green card when we were newly weds. Had a great experience through it all. Very knowledgeable and professional!
Response from the owner:David, it was my absolute pleasure!
Gary H.
Worked with Kim and Eliza over the last several months. They truly are experts and wonderful to work with. We had a successful outcome as a result of their work!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for the positive review! We truly enjoyed working with you. You will always be one of Eliza's favorites! We appreciate how dedicated you are and quick to respond to emails. We look forward to working with you again in the future.
Rebekah H.
Kim was a beacon of clarity during a frustrating and confusing process. I initially tried to file our marriage green card application on my own and only realized later that I had submitted just one of several required forms. I was overwhelmed and worried I’d make serious mistakes. From the moment we started working with Kim, everything changed. She answered all our questions with patience, simplified the entire process, and brought us peace of mind. She even met with us on Christmas Eve to help finalize our packet so we could submit it ASAP. When we got our interview notice, she responded quickly—scheduling a late-night Zoom call to walk us through what to expect and gave us a detailed checklist to stay organized. Thanks to her guidance, we felt confident and prepared—and the interview went smoothly. Kim is not just a knowledgeable attorney, but a kind and supportive person who genuinely cares about her clients. We’re so grateful for her help and can’t recommend her enough!
Response from the owner:Thank you for your kind words. You were truly a pleasure to work with. I don't routinely schedule to meet with clients on Christmas Eve or holidays in general. That said, your efforts were so sincere and I could not help but want to help you. Wishing your family much happiness.
J
Kim, Beca, and the entire team at Buhler Thomas Law were fantastic in our process of securing permanent residency, to say the least. From beginning to end, we received detailed, thorough, timely, and helpful communication about every step of the process. They were always quick to answer questions as well, but above all, we could tell that this team genuinely cared about us. The excitement we felt together as we reached each milestone of the process was tangible and means a lot. I cannot recommend this team enough for any immigration legal needs one might have.
Response from the owner:We have many wonderful clients that we enjoy working with. You two are among our favorites. We appreciate how responsive you bother were to our emails and calls. More importantly though we appreciate how helpful and kind you both were in how you both were in how you communicated. It truly was our pleasure to work with you.
Vale D.
Very impressed with the work that was completed. I've worked with many law firms & attorneys from many different industries. Kim & he team are by far the most impressive in this field than anybody else. I plan to work with them in a few years again. Thanks Kim & team!
Response from the owner:Thank you, thank you, thank you! Your review is so appreciated during this chaotic time in our nation. Our sincerest gratitude for taking this time to write this review.
Yolanda O.
Kim and Eliza are amazing to work with! They have helped us through 2 H1B processes. Their attention to detail, thorough communication and encouragement made a complicated process easy and smooth on our end. I highly recommend them for your immigration needs.
Response from the owner:I wish all our clients were as responsive as you were. It was our pleasure to work with you.